PRSIndia
Published on PRSIndia (https://www.prsindia.org)

> Politics of defection

Politics of defection [1]

Rohit's picture
Submitted by Rohit on Tue, 03/01/2011 - 15:20
Politics of defection

In a recent judgement, the Karnataka High Court upheld the disqualification of five independent MLAs from the Assembly. These MLAs, who had previously served as Ministers in the Yeddyurappa government, were disqualified along with 11 others after they withdrew their support to the government. The disqualifications raise some important questions on the working of the anti-defection law. While the law was framed in 1985 with the specific intent of 'combating the evil of political defections', over the years several unanticipated consequences have come to the fore. The primary among these is the erosion of independence of the average legislator. The need for an anti-defection law was first felt in the late 1960s. Of the 16 States that went to polls in 1967, Congress lost majority in eight and failed to form the government in seven. Thus began the era of common minimum programmes and coalition governments. This was accompanied with another development - the phenomenon of large scale political migrations. Within a brief span of 4 years (1967-71), there were 142 defections in Parliament and 1969 defections in State Assemblies across the country. Thirty-two governments collapsed and 212 defectors were rewarded with ministerial positions. Haryana was the first State where a Congress ministry was toppled. The Bhagwat Dayal ministry was defeated in the Assembly when its nominee for speakership lost out to another candidate. Congress dissidents defected to form a new party called the Haryana Congress, entered into an alliance with the opposition and formed a new government under the Chief Ministership of Rao Birender Singh (also a Congress defector). Haryana thus became the first State to reward a defector with Chief Ministership. Another Haryana legislator, Gaya Lal, defected thrice within a fortnight. The now well know terms 'Aya Ram' and 'Gaya Ram' that are often used to describe political turncoats owe inspiration to him. It was to address this issue that the anti-defection law was passed in 1985. This law amended the Constitution and added the Tenth Schedule to the same. The Supreme Court, in Kihota Hollohon vs. Zachilhu (1992), while upholding the validity of the law held that decisions of disqualification shall be open to judicial review.  It also made some observations on Section 2(1) (b) of the Tenth schedule. Section 2(1) (b) reads that a member shall be disqualified if he votes or abstains from voting  contrary to any direction issued by the political party. The judgement highlighted the need to limit disqualifications to votes crucial to the existence of the government and to matters integral to the electoral programme of the party, so as not to 'unduly impinge' on the freedom of speech of members. This anti-defection law has regulated parliamentary behaviour for over 25 years now. Though it has the advantage of providing stability to governments and ensuring loyalty to party manifestos, it reduces the accountability of the government to Parliament and curbs dissent against party policies. In this context, Manish Tewari's private member bill merits mention:  he suggests that anti-defection law be restricted to votes of confidence and money bills.  Such a move will retain the objective of maintaining the stability of the government while allowing MPs to vote freely (subject to the discipline of the party whip) on other issues. This brings us to the question - Is the anti-defection law indispensable? Is defection peculiar to India? If not, how do other countries handle similar situations? It is interesting to note that many advanced democracies face similar problems but haven't enacted any such laws to regulate legislators. Prominent cases in UK politics include the defection of Ramsay Macdonald, the first Labour Prime Minister, in 1931. He defected from his party following disagreements on policy responses to the economic crisis. Neither Macdonald nor any of his three cabinet colleagues who defected with him resigned their seats in the House of Commons to seek a fresh mandate. Australian Parliament too has had its share of defections. Legislators have often shifted loyalties and governments have been formed and toppled in quick succession. In the US too, Congressmen often vote against the party programme on important issues without actually defecting from the party. India might have its peculiar circumstances that merit different policies.  But, the very fact that some other democracies can function without such a law should get us thinking. Sources/ Notes: [1] PRS Conference note: The Anti-Defection Law – Intent and Impact [2] [2] Column by CV Madhukar (Director, PRS) titled 'Post-independents' in the Indian Express [3]

Parliament [4]
Image: 
Aya Ram [5],
Bhagwat Dayal [6],
coalition [7],
defection [8],
Defector [9],
Gaya Lal [10],
Gaya Ram [11],
Karnataka High Court [12],
Kihota Hollohon [13],
Ramsay Macdonald [14],
Rao Birender Singh [15],
Subhash Kashyap [16],
The Politics of Power [17],
Yeddyurappa [18],
Zachilhu [19]
  • What We Do
  • Board of Directors
  • Team
  • Opportunities at PRS
  • Disclaimer
Copyright © 2021 prsindia.org All Rights Reserved.
teen porn sikiş izle eskişehir escort bodrum escort bayan Eskişehir Escort Escort Eskişehir Kuzen Seks Hikayesi Amatör Porno Bodrum Escort olgun porno İzmit merkez escort mersin escort kocaeli escort eskişehir escort Stepmom licks sad teen in bedroom Женщина нежно лижет анус приятного мужика Girls equipped with big asses ready to get fucked hard Cute Sunny Redhead teeny taking fat cock Sexy teen vuole un hard martellante Super Hot Big Boobs MILF Has Hot Sex izmir escort baymavi giris escort bayan escort beylikduzu cratosslot hd xxx videos kocaeli escort Bakırköy Escort Bakırköy Masaj Taksim Spa izmir escort istanbul escort pendik escort Ataşehir Escort Seks Hikayesi Ataköy Escort Escort Ataköy Ataköy Bayan Escort Ataköy Bayan Ataköy Escort Hatun Escort Bayan Ataköy Yeni Escort Endüstriyel Mutfak Havalandirma escort denizli izmir escort bayan escort izmir escort izmir escort mersin altyazılı porno aydin escort hatay escort sivas escort sex stories kahramanmaraş escort beylikdüzü escort avcılar escort şirinevler escort esenyurt escort seks hikayesi elexbet vdcasino asyabahis giris escort izmir sekabet edirne escort seks hikayeleri Rug munch and fine sex Seks hikayesi sikiş hikayeleri Taksim Spa Escort Bayan instagram takipci satin al takipçi satın al
1xbet asyabahis betebet betgaranti betlike betvole ligobet pinbahis polobet verabet

Source URL: https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog/politics-defection

Links
[1] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog/politics-defection
[2] https://www.prsindia.org/uploads/media/Note%20on%20Anti-Defection.pdf
[3] http://www.indianexpress.com/news/postindependents/751205/
[4] https://www.prsindia.org/blog-category/parliament
[5] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1381
[6] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1382
[7] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1383
[8] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=884
[9] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1384
[10] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1385
[11] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1386
[12] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1387
[13] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1388
[14] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1389
[15] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1390
[16] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1391
[17] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1392
[18] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1393
[19] https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog?tag_term=1394